Russia: Is Coercive Psychology Staging A Comeback?
(RFE/RL) — It has been more than a month since Larisa Arap was forcibly entered into a psychiatric hospital ward in Russia’s northern Murmansk Oblast.
Arap, who has undergone debilitating sedation and alleged beatings since her hospitalization on July 5, had sought mental health treatment in the past. This time, however, she says the treatment has nothing to do with her condition — and everything to do with her reports on child abuse in local psychiatric wards.
Arap alleged that children and adolescents held in the Murmansk regional psychiatric hospital in the remote city of Apatity were regularly subjected to electroshock treatment and sexual abuse.
Her article, entitled “Madhouse,” was published June 8 in the Murmansk edition of “March of Dissent,” the newspaper tied to the United Civic Front (OGF) opposition coalition led by Garry Kasparov. Arap is an OGF member and close to the time of her article’s publication attended a Murmansk rally protesting the policies of Russian President Vladimir Putin.
Detained, Then Drugged
On July 5, during a routine medical examination, Arap’s doctor asked if she had authored the piece on the psychiatric wards. Within hours, the 49-year-old Arap was detained by police and then taken by ambulance to a Murmansk hospital where she was injected with drugs that blurred her vision and left her weak and unable to maintain her balance.
On July 26, she was relocated to the Apatity facility she described in her article. Her case has drawn heated criticism from people who see the spectre of the Soviet-era “psikhushka” — psychiatric wards used for the involuntary detention of political opponents of the state — resuming its role as a tool of repression.
Arap says her doctors have refused to comply with recommendations that she be released, or even say when their own commission will meet to discuss her case.
Russian human-rights ombudsman Vladimir Lukin this week called for Arap’s release. Lukin called for an independent assessment of Arap after human-rights groups, the OGF, and members of her family claimed she had been forcibly detained in retaliation for her article.
Yury Savenko, president of Russia’s Independent Psychiatric Association, led the expert commission chosen by Lukin to examine Arap. He says that although Arap shows signs of mental instability — she admits to being briefly hospitalized at Apatity in 2004 for stress and insomnia — the forced hospitalization she is being subjected to is in no way necessary.
“Our group managed to meet with her, despite every possible obstacle being put before us,” Savenko says. ” We studied medical documents and materials related to the case, and spent an hour and a half with her. The result was that we came to the conclusion that we’re dealing with a person who is in fact ill. There are no ‘politics’ behind this. However, the politicization of our entire life is such that these patients become the first victims of the situation. And it’s been revealed with unusual clarity that punitive psychiatry, so-called ‘police’ psychiatry, is alive and well. Because Larisa Arap, from the very beginning, presented no immediate danger to herself or others.”
He added that under the circumstances, the forced treatment was likely to worsen, rather than alleviate, Arap’s condition.
Expert Opinion Ignored
Savenko’s commission presented its findings to Lukin, who called for Arap be discharged from the Murmansk hospital. A court in Apatity, however, ignored the recommendation and ruled that Arap’s hospitalization should continue.
In an interview with RFE/RL on August 16, Arap said that her doctors have refused to comply with the recommendation or even say when their own commission will meet to discuss whether she should be released.
ombudsman, Lukin does not have the authority to interfere in the workings of the court. But he expresses hope that the advice of the expert commission would be more thoughtfully considered in an appeal.
“Considering the somewhat politicized situation that’s arisen around this case, the sooner she gets out of hospital treatment and into at-home care, the better,” he says.
According to data from the Independent Psychiatric Association, as many as 5 to 7 percent of the patients hospitalized in medical facilities like the Murmansk hospital are undergoing involuntary treatment.
“Psychiatry in Russia today is broadening its repressive functions and the use of involuntary measures in relation to citizens,” says Lyubov Vinogradova, executive director of the Independent Psychiatric Association, who joined Savenko on the expert commission that met with Arap.
Vinogradova calls Arap’s hospitalization “involuntary and a violation of human rights.”
The New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) this week published an open letter calling on President Putin to honor the findings of Lukin’s expert commission and ensure that Arap is immediately released and that a criminal investigation is opened against those responsible for her detention and treatment.
“The horrifying method of forcible psychiatric detention as punishment for dissent was a trademark of the Soviet past and has no place in a new, democratic Russia,” the CPJ statement says.
(RFE/RL correspondents Svetlana Volskaya and Olga Vakhonicheva contributed to this report.)