11/20/24: Michael Simonson found William (Bill) Lubov to represent David and Mr. Lubov requested the hearing be continued (delayed) to any day from December 3rd to December 13th to allow him to prepare.
11/19/24: Regions hospital has asked to add clozaril (Clozapine) to the drugs they can force into David.
11/15/24: Annie Singer’s new YouTube Video is now up, Psychiatric Survivor Needs Your Help!!! Pack the Court to Tell the Judge NO FORCED ELECTROSHOCK.
November 13, 2024 Update
Recent News
The hearing date on the the new Petition to Electroshock David Russell against his will has been changed to November 25th at 11:30 AM Central Standard Time. We have acquired the login information which is https://zoomgov.com/join Meeting ID: 161 324 7575 | Passcode: 246968
The name of the attorney appointed to represent David Russell, David Jones (Jones) blatantly and proudly works against David Russell’s wishes and interests, constituting ineffective representation and violations of the Minnesota Rules of Projessional Conduct for attorneys. As previously reported, Jim Gottstein wrote the Judge detailing this, including presenting the type of evidence Jones should have and should be introducing on behalf of his putative client. This letter was removed from the court file at Jones’ request and the judge informed Jim she won’t read it.
Since then, Michael Simonson, a professional publicist/journalist recruited Toby Watson, PhD, an expert on electroshock, to examine David Russell remotely and potentially testify on his behalf. Mr. Simonson has contacted Jones repeatedly about this and received no response. Instead, for a second opinion, Jones informed the court that “any examiner from the roster” who regularly testify in favor of forced electroshock is “acceptable.” Also, Daniel Fisher, MD, the fabulous psychiatric survivor psychiatrist is potentially willing to testify on David’s behalf after talking with him.
Finally, David has informed us that the guardian/conservator appointed dominion over him has his clothes now. It seems quite likely this was a result of your efforts. Thank you! Speaking of the guardian, according to the new Electroshock Petition, Brittany Dannehy has been designated as the guardian/conservator appointed dominion over him. It is likely the previous one quit because of your efforts, hopefully, because she didn’t want to participate in what Catholic Charities is doing to David.
Calls to Action
- Continue to contact Fox the Shock Doc, educating her about electroshock and demand she withdraw the electroshock petition. We are pretty sure Fox’s e-mail address is lindsay.c.fox@healthpartners.com. Calls to her are routed through the especially abusive unit David is on and flooding them with calls is too likely to result in retaliation against David so we are not recommending that.
- Contact David Jones, David Russell’s pretend lawyer and demand he withdraw as David’s attorney or properly represent David Russell, including by calling Dr. Watson or Dr. Fisher, or both, on David’s behalf. Jones’ contact information is (507) 289-4000 jones.david@joneslawfirm.net.
- Contact Brittany Dannehy, the new guardian even if you have reached out to her previous guardian. Her phone number is listed as 507-470-0438 and e-mail bdannehy@ccsomn.org.
- You might also keep an eye out for a new YouTube video on Annie Singer’s channel to share on Social Media, including commenting on Regions Hospital’s Facebook and LinkedIn pages, and directing ire @RegionsHospital on X. We will will try to post it on David’s MindFreedom Shield Alert page as soon as it goes up, if it does.
You may find Sarah Price-Hancock’s, Susan Roger’s and Jim Gottstein’s e-mails useful to use on the harms of electroshock and Jim Gottstein’s e-mail includes references to the United Nations’ and the World Health Organization’s determination that electroshocking someone against their will can constitute torture in violation of international law. Other potential points to be made are:
- David Russell has the right to have autonomy over his body.
- Honor David’s request for talk therapy instead, which the judge ordered as the “facility deems appropriate.”
Please let us know what actions you have taken to support David by posting them in the Comments below.
Update November 12, 2024
Emergency Meeting to Prepare for David’s Hearing
Wednesday, November 13, 2:00 pm pacific
See full announcement and details to attend HERE
Update: November 4-7, 2024
Latest News
11/7/2024. A Petition to start electroshocking David against his will again was filed today and the hearing set for November 21st at 3:00 PM Central Time. The link for the hearing is probably https://www.zoomgov.com/j/1613247575, meeting ID 161 324 7575, passcode is 246968. If we receive a different link we will provide an update. People weren’t allowed in for the hearing in May, but were for the hearing in August after Jim Gottstein wrote the judge, but it seems fairly likely people won’t be allowed into this one. Still it will show solidarity for people to show up even if you aren’t let in.
On November 5th, David Jones, David Russell’s appointed lawyer, asked the judge to remove Jim Gottstein’s November 4th letter from the court file, which she ordered the same day. Jim sent a follow-up letter today asking if the judge was going to respond to the serious charge about the improper representation of Mr. Russell by Mr. Jones, and the judge had Mr. Gottstein informed she would not be reading the letter.
11/4/2024David has been removed from the IRTS (Intensive Residential Treatment Services) where he was staying for making complaints about abusive staff and taken three hours away to Regions Hospital in St. Paul, which is a much more abusive hospital than even Mayo. David was placed in solitary confinement for four days with his infraction being “flipping off” a nurse for lying about what drugs they were pumping into him. He tries to lodge complaints but the staff turn their name badges around so he can’t see them and is punished for making complaints.
On November 1st he was told they are planning to electroshock him against his will again. Now he is being told if he doesn’t misbehave they won’t electroshock him. That certainly sounds like punishment. However, the current order allowing “any facility with the appropriate levels of training and staff” to electroshock David against his will expires on November 8th, just a few days away.
On November 4th, Jim Gottstein wrote a letter to the judge about David’s lawyer failing to provide effective representation and violating his ethical obligations. The letter also lays out the sort of evidence that should have been presented against drugging and electroshocking him against his will, including comments by internationally known expert on electroshock, John Read, PhD, exposing the untruthful testimony of Dr. Schak in obtaining the forced electroshock order.
The incomparable Annie Singer has produced a video for use on Social Media platforms.
TikTok https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZP8LewXD3/
YouTube: https://youtu.be/i3iTnZKO1to?si=Z0pyNYNkOlU8W9Pa
There is a 20-minute audio recording of Jim Gottstein speaking with David on November 1st, during which Dr. Lindsay C. Fox came up and talked to David about electroshocking him against his will. Jim reports that even before Fox came up, it was the most angry he had heard David, the point being that it certainly doesn’t justify being locked up or shocked against his will. Not that anything would. We are looking for a direct number for Fox, but we guessed Fox’s e-mail address to be lindsay.c.fox@healthpartners.com, and e-mails from Sarah Smith and Jim Gottstein didn’t bounce so it seems like that might be it. If you find a good number for Fox, please e-mail us at shield@mindfreedom.org.
David was not able to take his clothes from the IRTS and he has been trying to get the guardian granted dominion over him to have them retrieved for safekeeping and delivered to him. The guardian has not responded. So, we are also asking you to call the guardian to demand they collect David’s clothes and other property for David.
Call to Actions
- Dr. Lindsay Fox is the doc threatening to electroshock David and we are asking people to e-mail lindsay.c.fox@healthpartners.com demanding that she not electroshock David against his will and discharge him to a suitable living arrangement.
- Lydia Stiehl, David’s appointed guardian. Demand that the guardian collect David’s clothes and other personal property for safekeeping and delivery to David.
- Phone number: 507-454-2270
- Email address: lstiehl@ccsomn.org
- Mike Hanratty, Guardian/Conservator Program Director at Catholic Charities of Southern Minnesota. Demand that the guardian collect David’s clothes and other personal property for safekeeping and delivery to David.
- Phone number: 507-454-2270 ext. 233
- Email address: mhanratty@ccsomn.org
- Social Media Video, post Annie Singer’s video on social media, including commenting on Regions Hospital’s Facebook and LinkedIn pages, and directing ire @RegionsHospital on X,
Please let us know what you do in support of David in the comments below.
Update: October 10, 2024
David has been told they are not going to electroshock him any more, which he attributes to all of the pressure people have put on as a result of his MindFreedom Shield Alert. David wants everyone to know how grateful he is for all the support he has gotten. Now, he is scheduled to be sent to an Intensive Residential Treatment Services (IRTS) tomorrow morning, October 11, 2024. The IRTS is somewhat less restrictive, but still bad.
Update: September 12, 2024
Latest news
David Russell has recently been psychiatrically reincarcerated and electroshocked against his will at least two more times at the Mayo Clinic at the time of writing, and he has now been electroshocked against his will 17 times by our count. This has clearly had negative cognitive effects on him, at least some of which are likely to be permanent.
David is being forcibly subjected to psychiatric incarceration and electroshock because he became upset when his appointed guardian, Lydia Stiehl from Catholic Charities of Southern Minnesota, refused to provide him with his financial information. David says he may have raised his voice somewhat, but did not yell. Whether Mayo Clinic and Catholic Charities admit it or not, they are retaliating against David for asserting his rights.
Guardianships are a common form of exploiting and disempowering people, and in this case David’s right to make his own legal and medical decisions has been revoked.
Call to action
Please redouble your efforts to advocate for David by contacting the following individuals involved in his case:
- Dr. Kathryn Schak, the doctor responsible for David’s electroshock at Mayo Clinic
- Secretary’s phone number: 507-255-2326
- Email address: schak.kathryn@mayo.edu
- Lydia Stiehl, David’s appointed guardian
- Phone number: 507-454-2270
- Email address: lstiehl@ccsomn.org
- Mike Hanratty, Guardian/Conservator Program Director at Catholic Charities of Southern Minnesota
- Phone number: 507-454-2270 ext. 233
- Email address: mhanratty@ccsomn.org
- Bishop Robert Barron, Diocese of Winona-Rochester and President of Catholic Charities of Southern Minnesota
- Phone number: 507-858-1242
- Email address: bishop@dowr.org
- Social media: Facebook | X (Twitter) | YouTube
Tips and talking points
- David should not be electroshocked because he does not consent to it and it is harming his health.
- His guardian should provide him with his financial information as he has requested.
- Bishop Barron should take responsibility for this horror being perpetrated under his watch. We believe he should be publicly shamed for what he is allowing to be inflicted on David. Jim Gottstein’s e-mail to Bishop Barron might provide talking points for your own actions in support of David.
- Bishop Barron’s Facebook page has over 3 million followers. While you can’t post on his main page, you can comment on his posts.
- His X (Twitter) account has over 200,000 followers. Send posts and replies to @BishopBarron pleading that he stop David from being electroshocked.
- His YouTube channel has over 525,000 subscribers. You can comment on the individual videos.
Note
Please remember that David is at risk of retaliation and you are supporting him under the MindFreedom banner. We ask you to take this into account in your social media posts, and when you call or write. Our mission statement is:
In a spirit of mutual cooperation, MindFreedom International aims to lead a non-violent revolution of freedom, equality, truth, and human rights in mental health care by uniting psychiatric survivors, consumers, and allies through movements for justice everywhere.
This is the spirit we want you to bring to this effort. MindFreedom thanks you for your support of David. David also always expresses his gratitude for your trying to help.
Update: August 5, 2024
David’s review hearing is now scheduled for August 19th at 1:30 PM Central Time. The link is https://www.zoomgov.com/j/1613247575, the meeting ID is 161 324 7575, and the passcode is 246968.
It is not unusual for court dates to get moved around.
Update: August 2, 2024
Latest news
We believe David Russell was electroshocked for the fourteenth time on Tuesday morning, and he was told the shock doc plans to do it again next Tuesday.
David, a software programmer who was psychiatrically imprisoned at the Mayo Clinic, suffered a potentially life threatening blood clot as a result, but that didn’t stop them from continuing to electroshock him against his will. We regained phone contact with David after he was transferred from the Mayo Clinic itself to an IRTS (Intensive Residential Treatment Services), and he tells us he is still transported to Mayo to be electroshocked against his will.
David has been put under guardianship, a common form of exploiting and disenfranchising disabled people, and in this case the right to make his own legal and medical decisions has been handed over to Catholic Charities of Southern Minnesota. Why does a religious organization have legal rights over a man’s life and body in a supposedly secular state? We must fight to ultimately end this, and immediately to get the Catholic Charities “guardian” to stop the electroshock torture of David Russell!
Thank you for all the support you have given David so far. A big thanks also to the Incarcerated Workers Organizing Committee for including David’s Shield Alert in their recent news bulletin.
Call to action
This week, please focus on Bishop Barron, archdiocese and president of Catholic Charities, who has the power to intervene and stop the shock!
- Comment and tag Bishop Barron on Facebook and X (Twitter).
- He will likely be posting a new video on YouTube on Sunday, which we encourage you to comment on as well.
- His phone number is 507-858-1242 and his e-mail address is bishop@dowr.org.
For examples of what to say to Bishop Barron, see this letter from Attorney Jim Gottstein.
There may also be a new video on Annie Singer’s channel based on this update within a day or so that can be shared, including on Bishop Barron’s social media.<./p>
If you can, please also try to join David’s court hearing via Zoom on Tuesday, August 19th at 1:30 PM Central Time. We will try and get the link information before the hearing and get it out to you. The date/time for this review hearing has been changed twice, already and we will endeavor to keep you informed about this as well.
Please let us know what actions you take on behalf of David by posting them in the comments below.
Update: July 29, 2024
The review hearing scheduled for July 31st at 9 AM Central Time in David’s commitment case has been changed to August 6th at 2:45 PM Central. We do not have the login information at this time, but hope to obtain it soon.
Update: July 24, 2024
David was discharged from the Mayo Clinic Psychiatric Prison today to a somewhat less restrictive IRTS (Intensive Residential Treatment Services) and we have not been able to regain contact with him yet. He is supposed to have access to his cell phone there, but didn’t know if the guardian paid his bill to keep it going. We expect to regain contact in the next day or so.
He hopes not being at the hospital means they are going to stop electroshocking him against his will, but Charles Helmer and Ray Sandford were both electroshocked on an outpatient basis in Minnesota.
A review hearing to extend David’s commitment will be held via Zoom on July 31st. You may be able to attend to show your support for him. The details of the hearing are as follows:
Date: July 31st at 9 AM Central Daylight TimeMeeting link: https://www.zoomgov.com/j/1613247575Meeting ID: 161 324 7575Passcode: 246968
At the last hearing a bunch of people tried to join and their screen names were changed to “Observer,” but they were never let in. Even though they were not let in, it showed the judge there are people supporting David. Maybe people will be let in this time.
Update: July 15, 2024
1:00 PM Central Time: Annie Singer has made a YouTube Video that can be shared on social media, Mayo Clinic is STILL torturing David Russell — You can help! She also has the video on TikTok.
8 AM Central Time: David has now been electroshocked ten times against his will.
1. June 13, 2024 2. June 14, 2024 3. June 17, 2024 4. June 19, 2024 5. June 24, 2024 |
6. July 1, 2024 7. July 3, 2024 8. July 5, 2024 9. July 9, 2024 10. July 12, 2024 |
David has been told they are going to reduce the frequency to once a week and then maybe to once a month. David thinks they are planning on moving him to a less restrictive setting and hoped that would mean no more electroshock, but both Charles Helmer and Ray Sandford were electroshocked against their will on an outpatient basis in Minnesota.
David was asked if he still wanted people advocating to stop electroshocking him against his will in light of the apparent lack of effect and he said yes. In fact, it took a sustained effort to stop the electroshocking of Charles Helmer and Ray Sandford before success was achieved.
Therefore we are asking people to continue to press the Mayo Clinic, especially Dr. Schak, and Catholic Charities of Southern Minnesota (Catholic Charities), which was granted dominion over David as guardian to stop the shock. David has not been told what they are trying to accomplish with the electroshock. The reason given in the Electroshock Order is that since David has “failed multiple neureleptic drug trials . . . [electroshock] is the next medical step.” As far as we know Schak.Kathryn@mayo.edu is still Schak’s e-mail address and the phone number of Schak’s Medical Secretary is 507-255-2326.
Bishop Barron, the head of the archdioces and president of Chatholic Charities, can be contacted and urged to intervene to stop the shock. We think Bishop Barron’s phone number is 507-858-1242, and his e-mail address bishop@dowr.org.
Bishop Barron’s X (Twitter) account has over 200,000 followers and posts and replies can be sent to .@BishopBarron asking that he intervene to stop David from being electroshocked. Bishop Barron’s YouTube Channel has over 525,000 followers and you can comment on the individual videos.
In addition, you can contact Governor Tim Walz and demand he look into the abuse of David Russel.
We are certainly open to suggestions for other actions that might be taken on David’s behalf. If you have any, please e-mail shield@mindfreedom.org.
Please comment below sharing the actions you have taken. Our web provider requires us to approve comments, so they may take a bit of time to show up.
Update: July 1, 2024
11:30 AM Central Time: Jim Gottstein talked to David and he was electroshocked against his will this morning, making it number 6 by our count.
4:00 AM Central Time: As we mentioned last time, the head of Catholic Charities of Southern Minnesota, Bishop Barron, is one of the most-followed Catholics in the world on social media. if we can get David’s Alert noticed on Bishop Barron’s social media that would be very good. The idea is to get him to intervene to stop the electroshocking of David Russell against his will.
Bishop Barron’s Facebook Page has over 3 million followers and while you can’t post on his main page, you can comment on his posts. It would not be surprising if these were deleted and people posting the comments were blocked, but we wonder how fast they can do that and how many of us will post there. That they remove the posts and block people over it, can be publicized as well. It will be interesting to see, and if you e-mail shield@mindfreedom.org about your experience with Bishop Barron’s social media we can post it on David’s MindFreedom Shield Alert Auxiliary Page.
Bishop Barron’s X (Twitter) account has over 200,000 followers and posts and replies can be sent to .@BishopBarron pleading that he stop David from being electroshocked. Susan Roger’s post on X can be reposted.
Bishop Barron’s YouTube Channel has over 525,000 followers and you can comment on the individual videos. One has almost 2,000 comments, so it is hard to get noticed there, but if enough comments are made that can have an impact.
Jim Gottstein’s e-mail to Bishop Barron might serve to provide talking points for your own actions in support of David, as well as the e-mails posted on David’s MindFreedom Shield Alert Auxiliary Page.
Finally, you can share Annie Singer’s TikTok Video on your social media. It uses the F word a few times so that is a consideration of whether and where you might post it. It is focused on getting people to contact Bishop Barron to get him to stop the electroshocking of David.
Calls and e-mails to Bishop Barron should also be continued; 507-858-1242, bishop@dowr.org.
Until our comment function is working reliably, please e-mail us with the actions you take so we can post them in the auxiliary pages we have set up as a work-around. Especially if you tried to leave a comment and were stymied. Unless you tell us otherwise, when we post your e-mails, we will remove your e-mail address.
Update: June 26, 2024
4:30 PM Central Time: An auxiliary page has been set up for additional information and as a workaround for the comments feature not working at the present time.
- Fabulous TikTok Post by Annie Singer
2:30 PM Central Time: The Mayo Clinic is electroshocking David against his will again in spite of it causing a potentially deadly blood clot last Wednesday. The callous disregard of David’s health, and even life, is stunning.
We understand David has been subjected to five electroshocks against his will:
- June 13, 2024
- June 14, 2024
- June 17, 2024
- June 19, 2024 (blood clot)
- June 24, 2024
They were going to shock him again this morning, but there was a mix-up and he ate breakfast so they didn’t subject him to it.
A volunteer has been able to obtain some of the court filings in the commitment/electroshock case. They are very short on facts as to why all this is being done to David. The Electroshock Petition does state that David cannot breathe on his own during the procedure. There is also a recording of the hearing last October in the guardianship case on David’s motion for a new attorney. His supposed lawyer essentially testifyied against David, demonstrating why David should get a new lawyer. When David accurately says the lawyers assigned to him do nothing for him, that is attributed to the ravings of a lunatic. We hope to get transcripts of the psychiatric imprisonment, forced drugging, and forced electroshock hearings.
Catholic Charities of Southern Minnesota, which has been granted dominion over David as guardian has done nothing to protect David. They could almost certainly have the electroshocking of David stopped. We have asked you to contact people in its guardianship office without response, and now we are asking you to also contact the bishop of the diocese and higher ups at Catholic Charities. Mike Hanratty who we have asked you to contact in the past should continue to be urged to do the right thing and stop David from being electroshocked. He has the power to do so. E-mails are good, but phone calls are better.
Bishop Robert Barron, Diocese of Winona-Rochester.
507-858-1242
bishop@dowr.org, or contacted through his secretary, Leandra Hubka, at lhubka@dowr.org.John Meyers, Catholic Charities Executive Director
507-454-2270
jmeyers@ccsomn.orgIsaac Landsteiner, Catholic Charities Director of Parish Social Ministry
507-848-8303
ilandsteiner@ccsomn.orgMike Hanratty, Guardian/Conservator Program Director
507-454-2270 ext. 233
mhanratty@ccsomn.org
You might use their Catholic Social Teachings webpage and/or Jim Gottstein’s e-mail to Bishop Barron for talking points in your phone calls and e-mails .
Let’s also try to shame Catholic Charities of Southern Minnesota and the Mayo Clinic leadership and board of trustees on social media.
Bishop Barron’s bio says he is one of the most-followed Catholics in the world on social media. Thus, flooding his social media could have a big impact.
3.1 million Facebook fans (https://facebook.com/BishopRobertBarron)
529,000 YouTube subscribers (https://youtube.com/user/wordonfirevideo)
205,700 Twitter followers (https://twitter.com/BishopBarron)
The commenting function on David’s Alert Page is mostly not working at the moment so, if you could e-mail shield@mindfreedom.org to inform us of your social media posts that would be great. Or any other actions you take to support David. We will try to at least add the social media posts here so people can can repost them or otherwise use them to support David. Frankly, “liking” posts does not accomplish anything in our view. We want to shame Catholic Charities, the Catholic Church in Southern Minnesota and the Mayo Clinic as well as enlist the public in the effort to stop David from being electroshocked against his will.
Update: June 22, 2024
First, an update on David. When he woke up Wednesday after being electroshocked for the fourth time, he had a blood clot in his arm. This is a known effect of electroshock and can be fatal. Presumably for this reason he was not electroshocked Friday. It seems likely their plan is to resume the electroshock once the clot has dissolved so we don’t know how much of a reprieve this might be. Therefore, the pressure should be kept on.
However, it turns out the phone numbers we were provided for Schak and Zorn are their personal cell phones and people were calling in the middle of the night. Or, at least that is what Mayo’s lawyer wrote in his cease and desist letter. In our Alerts and Updates we say to to take into account you are advocating under the MindFreedom banner. We haven’t specified what that means exactly, but it doesn’t mean calling people in the middle of the night. While what Schak and Mayo are doing is reprehensible to say the least, constituting torture, MindFreedom chooses to take a higher road than Mayo. Not only do we think it is the right thing, we believe it is more effective, especially in the long run. We therefore ask that you stop calling those phone numbers. We have gotten Mayo’s attention. You might be interested in Jim Gottstein’s response to the cease and desist letter.
Over the weekend, let’s see if we can build a social media campaign focusing on Mayo’s Leadership and Board of Trustees. The idea is to draw their attention to what Mayo is doing and ask them to stop the Mayo Clinic from electroshocking David Russell against his will, as well invite others to join this effort. Are they pleased with being associated with an organization that is inflicting torture? “Liking” a post doesn’t accomplish this. The goal is to get wide exposure of what the Mayo Clinic is doing, garnering support, sympathy, and empathy for David. Sarah Price Hancock’s e-mail to Governor Waltz and people at the Mayo Clinic can be used to make points. So can PsychRights’ 2011 letter to the FDA.
Please put a link to your social media posts in the comments below so others can repost. Our system requires approval so it might take a bit before it shows up.
Update: June 20, 2024
David Russell has been electroshocked against his will four times now: Thursday, June 13th, the very next day on Friday, June 14th, Monday June 17th, and Wednesday, June 19th. They won’t tell him how many times they are going to electroshock him, but it is likely he will be shocked again on Friday, June 21st, unless we can get it stopped. We need to keep the pressure on.
It would be great if you would call them and demand that the Mayo Clinic quit electroshocking David Russell against his will. It is believed Dr. Schak can have the shock stopped on her order.
Also, Catholic Charities, the guardian granted dominion over David, should not be let off the hook. The legal rationale for overriding David’s choice not to take electroshock is he lacks capacity (is imcomptent) to make such a choice. As his guardian, Catholic Charities is almost certainly allowed to choose that David not be electroshocked. However, instead of exercising independent judgment, Catholic Charities is just accepting what Mayo wants to do to David. There is a new person assigned to David by Catholic Charities, Lydia Stiehl. Ms. Stiehl’s e-mail address is lstiehl@ccsomn.org and her phone number is 507-454-2270. It would be great if you could contact her and demand she have the shock stopped. We don’t have her extension so you will have to ask to be transferred to her. The head of Catholic Charities guardianship program is Mike Hanratty and he should be called as well. He is at extension 233 of the same phone number, 507-454-2270, and his e-mail address is mhanratty@ccsomn.org.
Jim Gottstein wrote Ms. Stiehl an e-mail that you can look at for ideas about what to say or write. Also, Sarah Price Hancock wrote an especially excellent e-mail to Governor Waltz and people at the Mayo Clinic that can also be used for talking points.
We will appreciate it if you let us know about e-mails you send or about calls you make in the comments below. Our system requires approval so it might take a bit before it shows up. If you have any problems, please e-mail shield@mindfreedom.org.
Also, please remember that David is at risk of retaliation and you are supporting him under the MindFreedom banner. We ask you to take this into account when you call or write.
David always expresses appreciation for what you are doing to try to stop him from being electroshocked, as do we at MindFreedom.
Update: June 16, 2024
Jim Gottstein has been speaking with David most days since April 29th. Before he was electroshocked on Thursday, June 13th, David did not exhibit any memory deficits. David did complain about the drugging affecting his thinking. After he was electroshocked against his will on Thursday David said it took him 30 minutes to remember where he was and had a splitting headache.
It is believed David was electroshocked against his will again the next day, Friday. Normally, electroshock is not given two days in a row. David was very disoriented, he couldn’t remember what day it was and was unclear on when he had been electroshocked. He was sure he had been electroshocked twice. When I talked to him later in the day, he didn’t remember he had talked to me earlier in the day. On Saturday, June 15th, David was feeling a little better, but was still having problems with his memory. Today, Sunday, June 16th, David says his memory has come back some, he is groggy and sore all over.
He understands they are going to continue to electroshock him against his will this coming week. Throughout this whole time David has said he is “scared shitless” as he saw someone being electroshocked to the point where they couldn’t talk and needed help eating. The brain damage from electroshock is cumulative, so the fewer electroshocks the better. David is a software engineer and he is legitimately worried the electroshock will make him unable to do that any more.
In addition to continuing to urge Dr. Schak to stop having David electroshocked against his will, you can contact Gianrico Farrugia, MD, Mayo’s Chief Executive Officer (CEO) by e-mail mailing him at Farrugia.gianrico@mayo.edu. Christina Zorn is Mayo’s Chief Administrative Officer and her e-mail address might be zorn.christina@mayo.org. Jim Gottstein e-mailed her, requesting a delivery receipt, which he has not received, nor has he received a bounce message.
Also, please contact Minnesota Governor, Tim Walz and ask him to have the forcible electroshocking of David Russell stopped.
Minnesota Governor Tim Walz
130 State Capitol
St. Paul, MN 55155
Fax:(612)296-2089
Tel:(612)296-3391
email: tim.walz@state.mn.us
web: http://www.state.mn.us
Alternate phone numbers:
Telephone: 651-201-3400
Toll Free: 800-657-3717
Minnesota Relay: 800-627-3529
Even though it is hard to imagine things getting worse for David, please recognize that he is at risk of retaliation and you are supporting David under the MindFreedom banner, so we ask you to take these into account when you call or write.
We will appreciate it if you leave a comment below with a copy of your e-mail and/or a description of your phone call or whatever else you might have done on David’s behalf and the response, if any. Our system requires approval of comments so it will take a bit for it to show up.
Update: June 13, 2024
Noon Central Time: Another volunteer has identified the following Mayo Trustees’ e-mail addresses.
- Dr. Katherine Baicker kbaicker@uchicago.edu
- Dr. Matthew R. Callstrom callstrom.matthew@mayo.edu
- Dr. Rafael Fonseca fonseca.rafael@mayo.edu
- Dr. Charanjit S. Rihal rihal@mayo.edu
Jim Gottstein’s e-mail to Michael Powell, the chair of the Mayo Clinic’s Board of Trustees, might be useful in drafting e-mails to these trustees. It might also be useful to keep in mind these are all MDs.
10:40 AM Central Time: Jim Gottstein talked to David and he was electroshocked. He said it took him 30 minutes to remember where he was, has a splitting headache and other typical negative electroshock effects.
10:20 AM Central Time: It appears Dr. Schak changed her e-mail address and it is now Schak.Kathryn@mayo.edu.
10:00 AM Central Time: One of our volunteers tells us the phone number of the Medical Secretary to Dr. Schak is 507-255-2326. Calls could be made to Dr. Schak there.
3:00 AM Central Time: David Russell is scheduled to be electroshocked against his will in a few hours, presumably on the order of the psychiatrist assigned to him, Kate Schak. It is believed Schak testified in court to obtain the court order and then in the face of our efforts to stop it told David she had decided against it. On May 8th, Jim Gottstein wrote to Schak asking her to get the court order revoked (vacated) because David was concerned Dr. Schak or someone else might change their mind. That certainly proved prescient.
Jim Gottstein just wrote Dr. Schak again, demanding that she stop the shock. She can almost certainly still stop the shock as of the time this is posted. Please e-mail or call Dr. Schak to stop the shock. Her e-mail address is schak.kathryn@mayo.edu. You can also try calling her at (507) 255-5555. This is where the Mayo Clinic has locked David up. If you can’t get through to her, please leave a message for her to stop the electroshocking of David Russell.
Please leave a comment below with a copy of your e-mail and/or a description of your phone call or whatever else you might have done on David’s behalf. Our system requires approval of comments so it will take a bit for it to show up.
Thank you for your support of David.
Update: June 12, 2024
Today at around 2:00 PM, David was informed they are going to start electroshocking him against his will tomorrow. They wouldn’t answer any of his questions, such as how many times they plan to electroshock him, what they expect to accomplish, or even why they decided to subject him to electroshock when they had previously informed him they were not going to. David suspects it is because he has been telling them about the corruption he has knowledge of.
Even if David is incorrect about the corruption, it is no justification for electroshocking him. If it is true, which probably at least some of it is, the electroshock could erase his memory about it. Electroshock is sometimes used for just this sort of purpose.
David witnessed another patient who was rendered unable to talk by electroshock and is terrified of that happening to him. Whether it gets that bad or not, Electroshock always causes brain damage, usually causing at least some memory loss. It is unpredictable, but many people are brain damaged so much they can no longer engage in their profession or are otherwise disabled.
It is unlikely Mayo Clinic executives and especially trustees know about the despicable actions of their employees and this should be brought to their attention. The Chair of the Board of Trustees is Michael Powell. Powell is the President & CEO of NCTA, The Internet & Television Association, and is the former chairman of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC). The e-mail address we have found for him is mpowell@ncta.commpowell@ncta.com
You can look at the e-mail Jim Gottstein sent Mr. Powell. Please let us know what you do on David’s behalf by putting it in the comments. Copying and pasting e-mails work. The system requires us to review comments so it might take a bit of time before it shows up.
We expect to be updating this page frequently in the next day or so with additional people to contact to try and stop the Mayo Clinic from electroshocking David. It is hoped Mr. Powell, or Eric Schmidt for that matter, who ran Google for ten years and is now the executive chairman of its parent company, would not be happy about bad publicity over this. If you find information on how to contact Mr. Schmidt, or other members of the board of trustees, please let us know. It also seems like a social media campaign could be good–if we got some reach with it. We could use some help with that, too. If you initiate or participate in a social media campaign to stop David from being electroshocked, please also put that in the comments or otherwise let us know.
Update: May 8, 2024
David just informed us he has been told they are no longer planning to electroshock him and going to work on discharge planning to a theoretically slightly less restrictive environment. YOU HAVE DONE IT!!!
There is no doubt David would have been electroshocked against his will without your efforts on his behalf. David wants everyone to know how appreciative he is. David said he called many agencies supposedly standing up for people’s rights and no one cared until he reached MindFreedom. He said he can’t believe people who don’t even know him have tried to help him. When he has a chance, he plans to thank us in the comments section.
The court order will likely still be hanging over David’s head so that is of some concern, but for now we should stand down from the advocacy. If they change their minds again David will try to let us know and we can start the advocacy again. We will also try to keep in touch with David just to make sure.
David is still trapped by the guardianship imposed on him and it would be great if he could get out from under that.
Update: May 7, 2024
This evening David informed us his new psychiatrist, Kate Schak, who testified in favor of electroshocking David against his will on Monday, told him today they were thinking about not going forward with the electroshock. While not definitive, it does seem hopeful.
We had asked the president/CEO of the Mayo Clinic to stop his organization from electroshocking David against his will on deck as the next action to take and Mr. Gottstein’s e-mail to Dr. Farrugia is in the comments below. It is still okay to e-mail Dr. Farrugia, but with the thrust being they should indeed decide not to electroshock Mr. Russell and inform him so. Dr. Farrugia’s e-mail address is probably farrugia.gianrico@mayo.edu.
Update: May 6, 2024
The court authorized the forced electroshocking of David Russell today. We understand the lawyer did not present any evidence against electroshock to rebut the untruthful testimony of the doctor. David’s statements about the harms were ignored, presumably as a product of his “mental illness,” i.e., that he was delusional in believing electroshock is harmful. There were at least eight people from MindFreedom who tried to attend the Zoom hearing, told they had been changed to observers but not let in. There were probably more who haven’t informed Jim Gottstein. If you are one of those people, you might drop in a comment below. We are not giving up.
Update: May 5, 2024
The court hearing to authorize electroshocking David against his will is scheduled for 10:00 AM Central Time, Monday, May 6th. We have found out it is going to be held by Zoom that one can join using ID Number 1613247575 and Pass Code 246968.
We don’t know if you will be thrown out if you join the Zoom, but it could have a salutary effect on the participants to know that people are watching what they are doing. Court rules will generally not allow you to speak.
We don’t know if chat will be enabled. If it is enabled, we know it will be hard to be civil in light of what they plan to do to David, but please be courteous and respectful in spite of that.
You can comment about your experience of and observations about the hearing at the bottom of this page. Our system requires approval of comments so it may take a little while before it shows up.
It is conceivable they will cancel or postpone the court hearing at the last minute. That is what happened Thursday when there was a retention hearing scheduled on whether to continue locking up David. The last we heard, David has not been told of the reason for the delay. Maybe his appointed lawyer just agreed to have David continued to be locked up? However, we don’t see anything to that effect on the docket sheet.
Update: May 2, 2024
David signed a release of information to provide information to James B. Gottstein, Esq., of the Law Project for Psychiatric Rights (PsychRights), but they won’t honor it, saying only his guardian can.
This is another reason to contact Mike Hanratty at Catholic Charities, David’s Guardian. His phone number is 507-454-2270, and his e-mail address is mhanratty@ccsomn.org. Jim Gottstein e-mailed Mr. Hanratty asking him to send him the Electroshock Petition and sign an Authorization for Release of Information to communicate with Jim. This e-mail is in the comments below.
So, today’s action is to contact Mr. Hanratty and demand (respectfully) that he send Mr. Gottstein the Electroshock Petition and sign an Authorization for Release of Information. His phone number is 507-454-2270, and his e-mail address is mhanratty@ccsomn.org.
You can post your e-mail and/or describe your phone conversation or voice mail in the comment section below. Our system requires moderation so it may take a bit for your comment to show up.
Update: May 1, 2024
At this point, the prime suspect for who filed the Electroshock Petition is Rob Morgan, the psychiatrist in charge of David where he is locked up at the Mayo Clinic. His e-mail address is Morgan.Robert@mayo.edu. We don’t have his direct phone number, but Jim Gottstein was able to reach him by calling the Unit at (507) 255-5555 and asking for Dr. Morgan. Dr. Morgan didn’t deny he had filed the Electroshock Petition and Jim asked him to withdraw it. Jim then e-mailed him, which is posted in the comments below.
Please e-mail and/or call Dr. Morgan and ask him to withdraw or dismiss the Electroshock Petition. While it is good to be firm and direct about the harm inflicted by Electroshock, please be respectful and courteous. You can then post what you e-mailed, or describe your phone call or voicemail, in the comments. If you previously contacted Catholic Charities and have yet to post what you did in the comments, you still can.
Speaking of Catholic Charities, as David’s Guardian, it should vehemently oppose the Electroshock Petition. They should not be let off the hook even if they didn’t file the Electroshock Petition. Mike Hanratty is the Program Director of the Catholic Charities guardianship program, his phone number is 507-454-2270, and his e-mail address is mhanratty@ccsomn.org.
Update: April 30, 2024
Catholic Charities denies it filed the Electroshock Petition and has been asked to vehemently oppose it and to identify who did. See, the exchange in the comment by Jim Gottstein below.
Shield Alert: Stop David Russell from being forcibly electroshocked
April 29, 2024: David Russell is terrified. He is currently a psychiatric prisoner at the Mayo Clinic in Minnesota and there is a court hearing scheduled for this coming Monday, May 6th, where they are on track to get a court order through a sham legal process to electroshock him against his will. David is terrified because he saw another patient who was electroshocked who now can’t even talk.
They really have David boxed in, taking his rights away through a guardianship/conservatorship and assigning him the same lawyer in both cases, who does nothing on his behalf according to David and as far as we can tell. Having a guardian means David is not allowed to make his own decisions, essentially putting him in the position of a small child with the guardian taking the place of his parents. The Conservator has control of David’s assets, including his income and bank account. David is an employed software engineer and the guardianship/conservatorship is absurd, bud sadly we see this all the time.
He is currently forced to take Zyprexa and has experienced the typical large weight gain associated with it. Zyprexa also dramatically increases the risk of diabetes. Previously, he was forced to take Risperdal, which has caused his breasts to swell up and lactate. This is called gynecomastia and is a well-established consequence of taking Risperdal.
This is all terrible and it would be great for David to be freed, both physically from psychiatric incarceration and forced drugging, and from the guardianship, but right now he desperately wants to avoid being electroshocked. We are still trying to find contact information for some of the people we would like to influence, but we do know Catholic Charities has been appointed guardian over David. The person there who is making decisions about David’s life is Brittany Dannehy whose phone number is 507-454-2270 ext. 241 and e-mail address is bdannehy@ccsomn.org. Mike Hanratty, is the Program Director of Catholic Charities’ euphemistically named Adult Advocacy Program and his phone number is 507-454-2270 and e-mail address is mhanratty@ccsomn.org.
David says he has not been given the electroshock petition, even though it is almost certainly legally required that he be given it. We can’t know for sure, but the Minnesota statute about the Guardian’s Power (see § (c)(4)(ii)) says it is the Guardian who is to file a petition for electroshock, so it seems good to call and e-mail Ms. Dannehy and Mr. Hanratty demanding that they withdraw the petition for electroshocking David against his will. Information on Electroshock is available here that might be useful in crafting e-mails or for phone calls. What they are planning on doing to David is truly barbarous and the United Nations has determined it can constitute torture (see ¶ 14) so it is right to be angry, but still please be courteous and respectful. If Catholic Charities did not file the Forced Electroshock Petition they can deny it and if so, should be asked who did. Please let us know.
You can leave comments below about steps you have taken and things you have learned and check back for updates.
Please stop violating this man’s civil rights. He has the right to refuse this treatment. There is no reason to force this on someone
I have sent another email, this time to the doctors of Mayo clinic.
“Doctors,
I am writing you to request that you do not administer ECT to David Russell against his will. I will not patronize you or belittle your professional esteem by detailing the harms caused by ECT and the lack of ethics that arise in cases such as this. Please reflect on the history of ECT and psychiatric treatment. Please reflect on the Hippocratic oath and your intentions to make a healthier and happier world. Please reflect on what is collectively understood as humanity and human rights in democratic societies.
Be well,
Gregg T. Holliday”
Please Dr Farrugia
Do not electroshock Mr David Russell against his will and please let him know this at the earliest possible.
Undue stress and aggravation of anyone’s psychological distress surely is not warranted not decent and surely not in David Russell’s interests as a fellow human being with a right to choices in healthcare and full citizenship and self agency.
God willing David Russell will not be electroshocked against his will and all forced and not consented to actions will be stopped immediately and you may be able to receive the wisdom of many who have written to stand up for Mr David Russell including mental health professionals ,lawyers and people of lived experience who vehemently opposed this outdated and inhumane electrical shocking of people’s brains. Nor should it be continued by clinics in any case with a conflict of interest of any kind in the name of research or teaching or any such experiments including supporting big pharmaceutical companies with compliant subjects effectively being electrically and chemically labotomised and deprived of free will over their own brains and bodies not to mention self agency, supported decision making, basic human rights under the ill thought premise that psychiatry is “right”. Please consider the damage and harm being instrumentally placed as a burden onto people just trying to get on with their lives without forced drugging and electroshock and other unhelpful strategies like using the legal system to incarcerate and increase the profit margins of clinics such as Mayo staying open.
At the expense of other men and women’s lives and brains.
Please refresh your memory on the letters and appeals for Mr David Russell and consult the likes of the experts that do know the harm of electroshocking from their own lives experiences or in advocating for others and helping to support the “patients ” who are being subject to this torture under the Geneva Convention Human rights..see Jim Gottstein Esq. refers to as well as countless others holding those responsible and accountable for this harm to humanity.
Please 🙏 stop the electroshocking of David Russell against his will and kindly advise him of this essential
de-escalation of events not only for his peace of mind and in the real interests of his well being which surely should be at the heart of the matter but in the interests of anyone seeking help that it is by their own choices on a client centred patient centred approach. This is not about power and control.
This is about justice mercy and appropriate action to stop 🛑 electroshocking of Mr David Russell against his will
If this was you would you seriously entertain this being done against your own will ,would any doctor think it right to do this in direct opposition of the their own consent for such barbaric experiments and procedures against your will for yourselves?
Please stop and let David Russell know.
It is also a known issue that peer support and such voluntary basis assistance for people especially could easily be provided outside the biomedical model and with my own experience of neurodiversity with no evidence of previous incorrect mental health diagnosis being evident since experiencing supportive psychology in my instance and being able to process normal life events and transitions such as becoming distressed ( normal emotional responses allowed to process such as grief or on any loss or difficult circumstances of shock or distress ) without forced drugging , not electroshock needed in life I know I should have much earlier had opportunities to seek help in this way without the interference of psychiatry. Sadly I now hope for the younger generation who may try have their mental health and neurodevelopmental rights respected as clearly many I T professionals have unfortunately already been exploited on their bright approach and cognitive ability whilst also being persecuted when they engage with any emotional distress that does not warrant electroshocking brain cells to make them more compliant for further psychiatric experimentation or to support salaries that support careers that rely on this continued non evidence based torture .. as a conflict of interest in pursuing this kind of maltreatment.
Anyone can invent studies and collaborate with others to support an argument that can be said to be scientifically proven.
Please stop the electroshocking against Mr David Russell’s will.
This is also an abuse being perpetrated on people vulnerable with disability and autism and ADHD and trauma responses. Particularly I would argue clinical settings are a source of trauma and are intended to force people into Jon consensual situations to benefit financial interests and a kind of medicine that causes distress and furthers the experience of trauma and for those on the spectrum a deep sense of distrust and fear is palpable in these settings and for lack of understanding.
Please stop the forced and non consented electric shocking of Mr David Russell.
I appeal to you Dr Farrugia this is so important and urgent please make a stand for mercy and justice.
Thankyou for all consideration in this matter.
It is hard to respect a clinic that carries out these practices but with respect I appeal to your better nature and prat to God for giving this thought and taking the right action to respect David’s will and agency as a young man that really needs to be getting back to his life with the right supports and his psychiatric rights respected.
Please advise Mr Russell of his not being electroshock so he may be relieved of the obvious distress this is causing him
Kind regards
Sincerely
Claire Gaudry
I have shared David’s predicament on Twitter
To: Farrugia.gianrico@mayo.edu
Dear Dr. Farrugia,
One of your patients, David Russell, reached out to MindFreedom to help him avoid
being electroshocked against his will by the organization you run, the Mayo Clinic. There
was a hearing yesterday, May 6th, at which the judge ruled in favor of granting the petition
to electroshock Mr. Russell against his will (Electroshock Petition).
Mr. Russell says he was never given a copy of the Electroshock Petition.
Electroshock is not effective for more than a short time, at best, and always harmful,
although the degree of harm varies. The harm is cumulative.
The United Nations has concluded Electroshock can constitute torture in violation of
International Law. See, UN Human Rights Council. (19 June 2020). “Mental Health and
Human Rights: Resolution 43/13 Adopted 19 June 2020.” A/HRC/RES/43/13. Geneva:
United Nations; UN Human Rights Council. (20 Mar 2020). Torture and Other Cruel,
Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment: Report of the Special Rapporteur.
A/HRC/43/49. Geneva: United Nations; Méndez, Juan E. (4 Mar 2013). “Statement By Mr.
Juan E Méndez, Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading
Treatment or Punishment, 22nd Session of the Human Rights Council of the United
Nations.” Geneva: United Nations. See also the related Report of the Special Rapporteur
on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, Juan E.
Méndez (2013), A/HRC/22/53. Geneva: United Nations.
Please stop your organization from Electroshocking Mr. Russell against his will.
Sincerely, nayan
From: Jim Gottstein [mailto:jim.gottstein@psychrights.org]
Sent: Tuesday, May 7, 2024 1:00 PM
To: Farrugia.gianrico@mayo.edu
Cc: jim.gottstein@psychrights.org
Subject: Stop the Mayo Clinic From Electroshocking David Russell Against His Will
Dear Dr. Farrugia,
I am with the Law Project for Psychiatric Rights (PsychRights) and work with MindFreedom, International. One of your patients, David Russell, reached out to MindFreedom to help him avoid being electroshocked against his will by the organization you run, the Mayo Clinic. There was a hearing yesterday, May 6th, at which the judge ruled in favor of granting the petition to electroshock Mr. Russell against his will (Electroshock Petition). I have spoken with Mr. Russell a number of times and he is terrified; he saw another patient electroshocked to the point where he could no longer even talk.
Mr. Russell says he was never given a copy of the Electroshock Petition and when he signed an Authorization for Release of Information to provide me with it, it was not honored on the grounds that only his guardian can authorize the release of Mr. Russell’s medical information. I have otherwise tried to obtain a copy of the Electroshock Petition without success, but I have no doubt it is untruthful and the doctor testifying yesterday in support of it did so untruthfully, knowingly or not.
Electroshock is not effective for more than a short time, at best, and always harmful, although the degree of harm varies. The harm is cumulative. See, January 24, 2011, PsychRights letter to the Food and Drug Administration and the Electroshock page on the PsychRights website.
The United Nations has concluded Electroshock can constitute torture in violation of International Law. See, UN Human Rights Council. (19 June 2020). “Mental Health and Human Rights: Resolution 43/13 Adopted 19 June 2020.” A/HRC/RES/43/13. Geneva: United Nations; UN Human Rights Council. (20 Mar 2020). Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment: Report of the Special Rapporteur. A/HRC/43/49. Geneva: United Nations; Méndez, Juan E. (4 Mar 2013). “Statement By Mr. Juan E Méndez, Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, 22nd Session of the Human Rights Council of the United Nations.” Geneva: United Nations. See also the related Report of the Special Rapporteur on Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment, Juan E. Méndez (2013), A/HRC/22/53. Geneva: United Nations.
Please stop your organization from Electroshocking Mr. Russell against his will.
Sincerely,
James B. (Jim) Gottstein, Esq.
President/CEO
Law Project for Psychiatric Rights
406 G Street, Suite 206
Anchorage, Alaska 99501 USA
(907) 274-7686
https://psychrights.org
The Law Project for Psychiatric Rights is a public interest law firm whose mission is to mount a strategic litigation campaign against forced psychiatric drugging and electroshock. We are further dedicated to exposing the truth about these drugs and the courts being misled into ordering people to be drugged and subjected to other brain and body damaging interventions against their will. Due to the massive psychiatric drugging of children and youth, PsychRights has made attacking this problem a priority. Children are virtually always forced to take these drugs because it is the adults in their lives who are making the decision. This is a national tragedy of immense proportions. PsychRights is seeking sufficient funding to increase its impact. See, Getting to the Next Level.
I also sent emails to Mr Hanratty asking him to stop the forced Electro shocks on behalf of David Russell.
I explained the dangers and serious after affects irreversible brain memory loss lack of cognitive function I am very saddened.
Donna Carol Jeans
Tried to attend on 2 different phones but only saw Judge Carmichael’s name. Observe that.
Sorry David we are not giving up ever!
So any kind of forced anything on anyone is abuse.
What their doing is changing people’s diagnosis to schizoeffective bullshit so they can give um neuroleptic medication.
Brian, David and my son Charles that I know of.
Also forced meds and shock is discrimination , abuse and a human rights violation. Any Minnesotaians wanna go protest in front of St. Mary’s? Saint my ass.
Sorry this is not fair. I did write a complaint to the UN today about David.Everyone should.
I tried to log in to the Zoom hearing, was never let in. Last week I called and left messages for both individuals listed from Catholic Charities. I also wrote a letter to all the biomedical ethics faculty members at the University of Minnesota and asked them to write and call. I pointed out that David is being forcefully medicated and that these medications cause adverse reactions that are frequently misdiagnosed as “mental illness,” would be glad to share this email list if desired. One of them, Associate Professor Elizabeth Wrigley Field, replied that she is against forced ECT and that she would call and write. I have forwarded the biomedical faculty the latest update. Tonight, I am going to look for other UMN faculty to write to. I am an alumna. I will also be contacting a former colleague of mine at Case Western Reserve University who is on their biomedical ethics faculty there and sharing this page with them and will share this with the biomedical ethics faculty at Hiram College, the sociology department at Kent State University, and with the legal faculty at Case Western Reserve. I will call and write Dr. Morgan.
I tried to join the hearing today but was late. I logged in around 10:15 and left at 10:22 as they had not let me into the hearing.
I am another who attempted to join ZOOM court hearing today. I attempted to join as “Gregg T. Holliday, for D. Russell”. I was prompted to have screen name changed to observer, then I was not let in after 30 minutes of waiting past the 10:00 AM start time.
I am disheartened to hear of the trial results.
The successes of MFI are still many and I am grateful SHIELD alert is an available resource for all.
I am one of the people that tried to attend the zoom court hearing. I put my name as Martha and my last name as David Russell. I waited for hours. I was told I had been made an observer by the host, but I never got to observe anything. What is the plan now? When do they plan to proceed with this torture?
I am so tired of tyrannical psychiatry!!! It must stop!!! They threatened to do ECT on my 27-year-old son. One day I received a phone call from the psycho doctor and he said, “Tomorrow I’m going to court. I need a guardian advocate to sign for ECT. I would like that to be you, but if you are going to go against me and all the physicians at this hospital, I will have to replace you”. I am not a legal guardian for my son but they make me his medical proxy or guardian i guess, whenever he has been in the hospital. The term guardian for them means “YES MAN”!!! I am allowed to make my son’s medical decisions as long as I agree with them. How is this America?? Since my son has been in the evil system, I’ve learned that we are no longer the “land of the free”. Not as long as they are allowed to torture people behind closed doors like this. I am still praying this be reversed for David! Somehow I got my son out of that hospital without ECT, but not before he was under iv drip anesthesia precedex in ICU for two weeks straight- never allowed to even get out of the bed- and more drugs and more mess. I have more stories of injustice.
Freedom in this country is dead in many ways. This is only one of the more serious ways. The Libertarian Party platform condemns involuntary psychiatry. Please see LP dot org.
I attempted to attend David Russell’s hearing today. I logged in at 8:05 am pacific (10:05 am central) and was finally let into the virtual courtroom at 11:47 am pacific (1:47 pm central). I didn’t see David Russell or his attorney so I figured that I was too late. Then, I read today’s Shield alert saying that the judge ordered David to undergo shock today. Somber news. Time to regroup for David.
We deserve rights. Wish I had more energy to help more in the fight. All I have left is prayer. May God’s grace fill the hearts of those who do not yet understand this struggle for our freedom to choose for our bodies & minds
I wrote to the Catholic Charities contacts and said that they must remember that every person is made in the image of God and has God-given rights. I asked them to please respect David’s right to say no. As a Christian I am appalled by what is being done here. That’s all I said to them. I might as well add here that so often I hear of court-appointed attorneys not doing diddly squat for the clients. This court was not a level paying field and I’m being charitable. It was actually a kangaroo court. Reminds me of something out of the old USSR. David and others who are in this position need to be able to get their own attorneys, pro bono if possible. I just feel that if not for fortune go I.
I am late in my response. I just had to fight to stop ECT for my son in 2022. I’ve been up against it seems the mafia at times for him for the past 10 years. I’m sitting here waiting to be let in as an observer to the zoom court hearing for David Russell. I called his guardian at Catholic Charities while I was driving this morning and just spoke from the heart as a mother who has had to face the system to protect her son from such harm. I asked the guardian to oppose ECT for David. I also requested that he allow Jim Gottstein Esq to view the petition. I mentioned that electricians and anyone who works with electricity are specifically trained to avoid electrocution because it is harmful. I also mentioned that if anyone arrives at a hospital having seizures, the first thing doctors do is try to stop the seizures because they are harmful! This is inhumane. I asked if he would submit his dog or family member to this ECT. I thought that Catholics regarded life. ECT harms life. I described how I was intimidated, gaslit, and more because I refused to let them electrocute my son’s brain. I also mentioned that I have recently received a phone call from an attorney’s office because another patient who was at the same hospital as my son died because they zapped his brain to death. They are suing now. I mentioned that this only traumatizes already traumatized people and that this is not therapy or treatment! I called upon his conscience and compassion. I did the best I could. I have much on my plate right now with my son in the ungodly system and now they want to drug my elderly mother. I am caretaker to both while tapering off medications I’ve been prescribed for the past 27 years. Praying for David. God and his angels are present in this court room right now. I know God has helped my son and he will help David today and from now on. We do what we can and God does what He does best. If he can turn the heart of a king- he can turn the hearts of everyone involved, or the right person who will reverse this harmful act.
Thanks Martha for supporting David when you have so much on your plate trying to protect your son and mother.
I hope for the best for you, your son and your mother. The system has hurt all of you. Yes God can turn the heart and mind of a king. Where I attend church we just had a long series on the life of David. Now we are studying Solomon, who took a great fall, but God brought him back. I was really hoping for David Russell. We all gotta pray.
If Dr. Morgan let’s our friend David Russell get SHOCKED then I will make sure that the world knows what’s happening at Mayo clinic St. Mary’s? Really? Maybe I should join the satanic
666 group these guys are in because it sure as HEAVEN goes against GOD! GOD specifically made people the way they are for his purpose.. NOT for the Dr.s, guardians, teachers, coaches or anyone else’s purpose. Don’t try to play ….I guarantee you that God opposes abuse and torture. God sees ALL.
It’s not just or right it’s for your Justus.
ANY kind of unwanted or forced touching , restraining, mocking is abuse.
Dr. Don’t pursue this ( please wake up DON’T DO IT)
Dr. Morgan!
Whatever happened to talking to a patient ( not for just a minute or 5)? How would you feel Dr.? Shock is never the answer. NOTHING JUSTIFIES IT. Any Dr. that doesn’t care is off my books.
God help you x 2!!!!!!
Honor thy patients wishes..not your pockets.
From the days when Benjamin Rush normalized his sadistic medical experimentation on unwilling captives until today, the psychiatric profession’s American legacy of flippantly inflicting harmful experimentation on unwilling captives continues. Dubious labeling and even more dubious “studies” are routinely rolled out that attempt to justify this abhorrent behavior.
While I marvel at the intrepidness of individuals who manage to turn macabre obsessions into lucrative careers, isn’t it time Psych grew up? Isn’t it time Psych divested itself of its obsession with abuse? Isn’t it time Psych looked at its historical and modern failings, its legacy of grandiose claims, crackpot theories, harm infliction, harm denial, overmedication, bigoted judgements, proliferation of medical misinformation. etc., etc., etc. and just stopped?
Yet another instance of a determination to march in the footsteps of the likes of Benjamin Rush has been brought into the sunlight by Mindfreedom, Intl. Acting on a plea for help from one of Mayo’s unfortunate captives, Mindfreedom has thankfully attempted to intervene and try to stop the psychopathic obstruction of David Russel’s rights to oppose Mayo’s nebulous “treatment” plans. That abuse is as ubiquitous as it is profitable in the psych industry is directly related to unchecked malevolent behavior like this that should have been banned decades ago.
No, I don’t believe – and never will – that ECT is harmless. I will never believe Psych is anything but harmful. I will never stop advocating against exactly the kind of behavior the Mayo Clinic is engaging in with Mr Russel. As a former Mayo patient myself, I’m well aware of the huge gap between the Mayo results and the Mayo hype. I urge you to separate the hype from the facts and rescind the forced electroshock order.
“The quality of most SECT–ECT studies is so poor that the meta-analyses were wrong to conclude anything about efficacy, either during or beyond the treatment period. There is no evidence that ECT is effective for its target demographic—older women, or its target diagnostic group—severely depressed people, or for suicidal people, people who have unsuccessfully tried other treatments first, involuntary patients, or children and adolescents. Given the high risk of permanent memory loss and the small mortality risk, this longstanding failure to determine whether or not ECT works means that its use should be immediately suspended until a series of well designed, randomized, placebo-controlled studies have investigated whether there really are any significant benefits against which the proven significant risks can be weighed”
Electroconvulsive Therapy for Depression: A Review of the Quality of ECT versus Sham ECT Trials and Meta-Analyses | Springer Publishing
Michael Hessler
Just came across this story: “Whoopi Goldberg’s mom forgot her children after undergoing electroshock therapy”
It goes on to say:
“Whoopi Goldberg’s mom was hospitalized for two years during the “View” co-host’s childhood — and lost memories after undergoing electroshock therapy.
Emma Harris didn’t tell Goldberg that she forgot who her children were at the time, waiting 40 years to share the “secret” with her daughter.
“She said, ‘I didn’t know who you were when I got out of the hospital,’” Goldberg, 68, writes in her forthcoming memoir, “Bits and Pieces: My Mother, My Brother and Me,” per an excerpt obtained by People Thursday.
At the time, the EGOT winner replied, “I’m sorry, what? I’m sorry, what?”
Harris then explained, “Yeah, I had no idea who you were. I just knew I never wanted to go back to that hospital. So I had to do everything I could.
“If they said the sky was green, and I could see it wasn’t green, and it was blue, I’d say, “Yes, the sky is green.” ‘Cause I never wanted it again,’” she continued.
Goldberg opened up more about the experience on “The View” Wednesday, saying her grandfather and father “OK’d that [her] mother get the shock treatment for two years” because “there was a time in this country when … any man involved in your life could make medical decisions for you.”
Sara Haines and Sunny Hostin expressed their “shock” that such treatment was used in Goldberg’s lifetime.”
Sirs,
I am writing to you today regarding the hearing on Monday for the forced ECT’s of David Russell. It is obvious David vehemently opposes ECT or there would be no need to go to court. David is terrified of the debilitating impact electrical currents surging through his brain will have on his memory, his cognitive abilities, and his ability to pursue his white collar career once he is set free. David has a right to be concerned. ECT is not without side effects and risk of death. My own grandfather died of a cerebral hemorrhage during an ECT that was administered to him against his will. His death was quite traumatic for my mother, her siblings and my grandmother. My mother’s family never recovered from the trauma and I still have residual trauma from it. I, myself, had forced ECT that I managed to stop before the full 12 sessions. I was losing precious memories of my children at the ages of 4 and 6 and found this to be horrifying. I still grieve the loss of those memories. Instead of my grief dissipating over the years my grief has only grown. My children are now adults and living their own lives. Now the memories of their childhood are much more important to me than ever before. I will never be able to tell my grandchildren what their mom and dad were like at the age of 4 and 6. How is this fair to the next generation? Trauma is inner generational and this type of trauma needs to stop. David is a bright man. It is obvious or he would never have been able to graduate from college and pursue a career in Software Engineering. Do doctors have the right to damage a man’s brain in pursuit of some pseudoscientific cure? Is it playing God to change the course of a person’s entire life by damaging his brain? Psychiatrists need to have the humility to admit that there is no proof mental illness exists. There are no blood tests or X Rays. You look at behavior and make a subjective diagnosis. I am not denying people struggle but to damage a person’s brain and body through electricity and drugs is not a compassionate response to people’s struggles. The chemical imbalance theory of mental illness has been disproven. It has been called a noble lie by many in your profession. In 2018 The United Nations called for all members states to ban all forced ECT’s and to reframe and recognize such ECT practices as constituting torture. (https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8710293/#:~:text=The%20United%20Nations%20has%20called,degrading%20treatment%20(UN%202018) It appears that even the UN agrees that doctors should first, do no harm. Mr Hanratty, as a Catholic, I do know Pope Francis would not approve of a Catholic pasrticipating in any way in an action that UN constitutes as torture. Many people who have experienced forced ECT find it be dehumanizing and truamatic. As an incest and rape survivor I find forced ECT’s to be far more horrifying and far worse than rape. As David’s guardian I expect you to protect David. Isn’t that what God calls us all to do — to protect the most vulnerable amongst us. I beg of you to please leave David Russell brain’s alone. Please cancel his hearing on Monday. Ideally, David needs his freedom to nourish his full potential as a child of God but for now I am asking you to please not damage David;s brain through forced ECT’s. Nobody should ever have the right to harm another person’s brain unnecessarily and against the will of the person being harmed. As the UN says, this constitutes torture.
Andrea Barnes
From: Jacek_Jack Haciak
Sent: Friday, May 3, 2024 10:28 AM
To: mhanratty@ccsomn.org; Morgan.Robert@mayo.edu
Subject: Please rethink your justification for forcibly using ECT with Mr. David Russell
Good morning,
I am a retired Licensed Psychologist in Oregon who has dealt with the statutory, clinical, and ethical issues of competency and autonomy in mental health. I have provided testing, assessment, and expert input for judicial consideration in cases dealing with civil commitment, guardianship, and conservatorship. Please halt the ECT trial for Mr. David Russell.
1. Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) has been modified over the years for safety, but still is found to have substantial cost/benefit risks:
A second independent audit of electroconvulsive therapy in England, 2019: Usage, demographics, consent, and adherence to guidelines and legislation https://bpspsychub.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/papt.12335
“Given the high risk of permanent memory loss and the small mortality risk, this longstanding failure to determine whether or not ECT works means that its use should be immediately suspended until a series of well designed, randomized, placebo-controlled studies have investigated whether there really are any significant benefits against which the proven significant risks can be weighed. (Read et al., 2019).”
2. Despite legal requirements being met for proceeding with forced ECT, the moral imperative for preserving autonomy does not go away. Autonomy is not a one-and-done ethical consideration no longer requiring attention once a judicial order has been issued. As we know in many instances, legal technicalities do not line up with clinical and ethical responsibilities in mental health. For example, in civil commitment law whenever a person demonstrably regains their ability to function safely, any past determinations abridging their autonomy rights then become null and void, and the commitment order is to be dropped. But this requirement is rarely implemented in clinical practice.
3. From available data, Mr. David Russell has recently demonstrated cognitive and adaptive functioning within normal limits to meet competency standards and make his own decisions, and he is opposing the use of ECT and able to clearly assert that. To proceed responsibly and ethically, there needs to be current evidence of incompetency shown to continue overriding Mr. Russell’s wishes and justify the forcible use of the high risk ECT treatment. To now point to a past set of circumstances when Mr. Russell possibly did not meet competency requirements, particularly given the gravity of the procedure being recommended against Mr. Russell’s will, the decision to proceed can no longer be considered to have valid, responsible, or moral justification either clinically or ethically without fresh evidence. No such evidence has been produced to my knowledge, and those in positions of responsibility are now obfuscating attempts by neutral observers to gain clarification. In the face of Mr. Russell’s current functioning, and how responsible parties are refusing to provide helpful information to prevent error, Mr. Russell may now be facing another instance of iatrogenic harm both emotionally traumatic and physically damaging.
Please look at the full array of responsibilities needing attention instead of just the technical legal order. Please do not proceed with Mr. Russell’s ECT unless he would consent/assent to its use.
Thank you.
Jacek (Jack) Haciak, PsyD, Director
DynamicChanges LLC
Salem, Oregon
I sent the following two emails this morning:
Dear Mr. Mike Hanratty,
I am emailing you as a concerned Minnesotan to request you do everything in your power to prevent Mr. David Russell from being subjected to ECT by force. It is beyond horrifying that Mayo Clinic is planning to force Mr. Russell to undergo ECT against his will, which amounts to torture, and as Mr. Russell’s guardian you must oppose this appalling violation of his human rights.
Please immediately sign an Authorization for Release of Information
for Mr. James B. Gottstein, Esq. and send the Electroshock Petition to him, in alignment with Mr. Russell’s wishes.
This is incredibly urgent as the court hearing is on Monday.
Thank you,
Ruby Cromer
________________________________________________
Dear Dr. Morgan,
I am emailing you as a concerned Minnesotan to request you immediately withdraw or dismiss the Electroshock Petition filed against your patient Mr. David Russell. It is beyond horrifying that you and Mayo Clinic are planning to force Mr. Russell to undergo ECT against his will, which amounts to torture, in an appalling violation of his human rights.
Please withdraw or dismiss the petition before the scheduled hearing on Monday. Do not subject Mr. David Russell to ECT by force.
Thank you,
Ruby Cromer
Dear Mr. Hanratty and Ms. Dannehy:
As you are, respectively, the Program Director of the Catholic Charities guardianship program, and the person who is making decisions about David Russell’s life, you have dominion over David Russell. So I strongly urge you both to put an end to the effort to force David Russell to undergo ECT.
I am the Director of the National Mental Health Consumers’ Self-Help Clearinghouse, and I work to provide accurate information to people with mental health conditions. And, since 1984, I have learned a great deal about the terrible impact that this controversial procedure can have on those who experience it, whether by force or with their (rarely truly informed) consent.
I emailed Dr. Morgan about this, and cc’d you both, but I will add that, in Matthew 7:12, Jesus says, “In everything, do to others what you would have them do to you.” (This is summed up as the Golden Rule, and appears elsewhere in the Bible too.) I believe you would not want to be forced to undergo a controversial and potentially extremely harmful procedure, so forcing David Russell to do so is against the teachings of Jesus.
Again, I urge you to protect David Russell, as your guardianship gives you the obligation to do.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Susan Rogers, Director
National Mental Health Consumers’ Self-Help Clearinghouse
https://www.mhselfhelp.org/
I’m going to send this email in a few hours when Minnesota starts work.
Dear Mr. Hanratty and Mrs. Dannehy, I am writing this morning concerning David Russell. I am told You have been appointed his Guardian. I’m asking You to send Mr. Gottstein the Electroshock Petition and sign an Authorization for Release of Information. From what I hear Mr. Russell’s wishes and even his rights have been denied. The first rule of medicine or healing is “do no harm.” Don’t make the situation worse by making Mr. Russell’s situation worse. Am I, or is anyone, expected to believe that this grown man who has functioned in society successfully for most of his life as a professional engineer, no less, is no longer able to speak for himself? Why not? I find it more likely someone is trying to silence him. Is that criminal? I’ve had my rights to speak arrested unjustifiably. A lot of people do. It doesn’t make it right or OK. His requests seem simple and completely reasonable. Be on the right side of history, even if that side loses. One of the world’s great religions says something about doing what is right over what is easy, and how self sacrifice in the name of truth and justice is more important than success.
Electroshock, really? Why? I accidentally touched an electrical outlet once, and only once. That hurt bad enough to knock me backward onto my butt. I think the electroshock to the head might feel, at least slightly more, uncomfortable? As I said, an electrical outlet hurt. How many times exponentially more powerful is the shock they’re going to give this man? This is inhumane and amounts to torture. I do not advocate torture. Certainly not under these ridiculously unnecessary circumstances. Everybody everywhere knows in their gut this is true. How much time have they spent on his case(?) to understand a lifetime of lived experience. If you’re not going to do the work and spend the time to help this man, the decent thing is to respect his wishes. Do you feel qualified to make these decisions for this man? Is anyone? Why can’t he make his own? Please send Mr. Gottstein the peitition if that is what Mr. Russell wants. thank you, John
Dr Mike Hanratty
Please dismiss electroshock and action a withdrawal of Petition for Electroshock for David Russell
Please provide on respectful demand Mr Jim Gottstein the Authorisation for Release of Information which already David Russell had signed and was summarily had his rights ignored with no consent given for the ElectroShocking.
Please provide the Petition for Electroshock to Jim Gottstein Esq. This maltreatment is otherwise known incorrectly as ECT amongst practitioners of this Geneva Convention recognised method of torture and Jim Gottstein Esq. has spoken to you and to my knowledge provided you with the relevant information on this issue regarding taking into account David’s wishes regarding his own consent not given for this position and vouching for David’s psychiatric rights.
Electroshocking is still used to subdue remove and modify a person’s natural process of grief and thinking feeling and responding and physically harms and distresses, damages, is not therapeutic and damages the brain , unlawful and unethical without consent. It is simply a choice to utilise power and control in institutions and for psychiatry’s benefit to ensure a compliant passive patient who can no longer communicate think feel and be themselves nor have restorative effect to their previously functional self. In David’s case this included employment and maintaining full personhood without being terrified of electric shock and incarcerated in chemical bondage in harmful drugs also non consented to and affecting his decision making and not being treated as any patient with choices as an adult human being. A supportive voluntary model of supports with directed supports by patience without drugging would enable David to once again live a life without brain damage and with freedom as a citizen with full rights he is entitled to.
Please withdraw the Petition for Electroshock as reasonable and necessary to David Russell’s welfare and future and hope.
Kind regards
Claire Gaudry
Correction spoken with Dr Morgan re previous email
Please STOP 🛑 a miscarriage of justice
Dear Dr Robert Morgan
As a matter of urgency
Please dismiss electroshock and action a withdrawal of Petition for Electroshock for David Russell
Please provide on respectful demand Mr Jim Gottstein the Authorisation for Release of Information which already David Russell had signed and was summarily had his rights ignored with no consent given for the ElectroShocking.
Please provide the Petition for Electroshock to Jim Gottstein Esq. This maltreatment is otherwise known incorrectly as ECT amongst practitioners of this Geneva Convention recognised method of torture and Jim Gottstein Esq. has spoken to you and to my knowledge provided you with the relevant information on this issue regarding taking into account David’s wishes regarding his own consent not given for this position and vouching for David’s psychiatric rights.
Electroshocking is still used to subdue remove and modify a person’s natural process of grief and thinking feeling and responding and physically harms and distresses, damages, is not therapeutic and damages the brain , unlawful and unethical without consent. It is simply a choice to utilise power and control in institutions and for psychiatry’s benefit to ensure a compliant passive patient who can no longer communicate think feel and be themselves nor have restorative effect to their previously functional self. In David’s case this included employment and maintaining full personhood without being terrified of electric shock and incarcerated in chemical bondage in harmful drugs also non consented to and affecting his decision making and not being treated as any patient with choices as an adult human being. A supportive voluntary model of supports with directed supports by patience without drugging would enable David to once again live a life without brain damage and with freedom as a citizen with full rights he is entitled to.
Please withdraw the Petition for Electroshock as reasonable and necessary to David Russell’s welfare and future and hope.
Kind regards
Claire Gaudry
To Dr. Morgan, Ms. Dannehy, Mr. Hanratty, et al.,
I understand that your patient, David Russell, may be forced to endure electroshock treatment and neuroleptic drugging against his will.
To introduce myself, I am a neuroscientist with special expertise in forensics, both criminology and criminalistics. And I am very concerned about your involvement in Mr. Russell’s situation. With urgency, I ask that you immediately withdrawal your electroshock petition.
Electroshock treatment causes irreparable physical damage to the brain at the neuronal level, adversely impacting cognition and mentation.
Neuroleptics are known to be ineffectual in treating mental disorders and side effects can be dangerous, as described in multitudes of modern scientific literature. Further, your forced therapeutics are a civil rights violation and may meet the criteria for torture.
Dr. Morgan, if you should damage Mr. Russell’s brain, then you could be held accountable for your decisions, especially noting that receive financial compensation for such violations. Would you be prepared for such consequences? How can you reconcile harming your patient?
Withdraw your electroshock petition.
Sincerely,